WASHINGTON — A New Report Calls for Overhaul of the U.S. Medicolegal Death Investigation System
A new report released by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine has found that the United States’ medicolegal death investigation (MLDI) system is deeply fragmented, underfunded, and inconsistent, particularly in cases involving deaths that occur while individuals are in custody. The report calls for major reforms to improve standards, infrastructure, and data collection, as well as stronger oversight at both federal and state levels.
Deaths that occur “in custody” encompass any fatality that happens from the moment a person first encounters law enforcement—such as during arrest or transport—through detention, trial, or incarceration, and even up to their release. These deaths, according to the report, are often examined within a system that lacks uniform practices and sufficient professional resources to ensure reliable cause- and manner-of-death determinations.
The report paints a picture of a system under strain: many coroners and medical examiners must work in outdated or unaccredited facilities, often without adequate training or certification. As a result, the accuracy of investigations into in-custody deaths can vary significantly from one jurisdiction to another. Building on a 2009 National Academies report on forensic science, the new study emphasizes the urgent need to modernize and standardize the MLDI system across the country.
John A. Rich, co-chair of the committee and director of the Rush BMO Institute for Health Equity at Rush University, noted that the credibility of the system depends on its scientific rigor. “Understanding why a death occurred and holding accountable those responsible for unnatural deaths requires precise methodology,” he said. “Our recommendations aim to create a stronger and more transparent system that benefits the public as a whole.”
To strengthen the nation’s medicolegal infrastructure, the report urges Congress to provide states with funding to upgrade facilities and increase coordination among local, state, and federal death investigation systems. It also suggests developing programs that enable coroners to collaborate with medical examiners and forensic pathologists, as well as creating research opportunities that bring together experts from multiple disciplines.
In addition, the report recommends that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, working alongside the National Institute of Justice and the National Institute of Standards and Technology, convene a national panel to define the types of in-custody deaths that should mandate an autopsy.
At the state level, the report calls for the licensure of all medicolegal death investigators, with continuing education requirements to maintain professional competency. States should also adopt reciprocity agreements to recognize licenses issued elsewhere. To ensure quality, every coroner or medical examiner’s office should implement annual peer reviews covering at least 10 percent of their cases.
Lack of Reliable Data on Deaths in Custody
Another critical concern highlighted in the report is the absence of comprehensive and reliable data on deaths that occur while individuals are in custody. Incomplete or inconsistent data make it difficult to safeguard the health and safety of those detained, as well as correctional staff, and hinder efforts to hold institutions accountable for preventable deaths. Existing data indicate troubling numbers of deaths by suicide and deaths that occur prior to conviction.
To address these gaps, the report recommends that Congress require all states to collect and publicly report detailed information on every in-custody death. It further proposes adding a checkbox to the U.S. Standard Certificate of Death to indicate whether a death occurred in custody. To ease the financial burden on local jurisdictions, Congress should also authorize funding for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to reimburse the cost of autopsies performed on individuals who die while detained.
Improving Testimony in Legal Proceedings
The report also addresses the impact that medicolegal investigators have on the justice system. The “manner of death,” which describes the circumstances under which a person died, is not always clear-cut and may rely heavily on the judgment of the investigator. When these experts testify in court, their statements can strongly influence verdicts or sentencing decisions.
Because of this, the report calls for new judicial standards to regulate how such testimony is presented in legal proceedings. “Given the weight that courts place on testimony from those investigating deaths, it is essential that this evidence meets rigorous scientific and procedural standards,” said committee co-chair Raymond J. Lohier, a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. He emphasized that better oversight can help prevent wrongful convictions or misinterpretations of forensic evidence.
The study also provides recommendations for federal and state courts, as well as other criminal justice stakeholders, to prevent the misuse or misrepresentation of expert testimony concerning cause and manner of death.
A Call for Reform and Accountability
The study, conducted by the Committee on Advancing the Field of Forensic Pathology: Lessons Learned from Death-in-Custody Investigations, was sponsored by Arnold Ventures, the Just Trust for Education, and Universal Music Group. The findings underline the urgent need for a coordinated national effort to ensure that every death in custody is investigated thoroughly, transparently, and scientifically.
Founded under an 1863 congressional charter signed by President Abraham Lincoln, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine continue to provide independent, objective guidance on pressing national issues. This latest report reinforces the principle that justice and accountability depend on strong, evidence-based public institutions—and that reforming the nation’s death investigation system is an essential step toward that goal.







Leave a Reply