Astrophysicist David Spergel has spent decades observing the US scientific system from nearly every possible angle. As president of the Simons Foundation, one of the country’s largest private supporters of science and fundamental research, he oversees both the foundation’s grantmaking work and the Flatiron Institute, its in-house research organization devoted to advancing computational approaches across many scientific disciplines.
Before entering philanthropy, Spergel built a distinguished academic and research career. He led major NASA science teams, including the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope, scheduled for launch in 2027, and the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe, a mission that helped establish today’s standard model of cosmology. He spent more than 30 years at Princeton University as a faculty member, including a decade as chair of the astronomy department, and now holds the title of Charles Young Professor of Astronomy Emeritus. A member of the US National Academy of Sciences, he has received numerous honors, including the 2018 Breakthrough Prize for his work on the early universe and two NASA Exceptional Service Medals.
In a wide-ranging conversation with Issues editor Molly Galvin, Spergel shared his perspective on how science philanthropy is adapting to major changes in US science policy, why deep federal funding cuts worry him, and where he believes American science may be headed in the next five years.
Spergel’s path into philanthropy was not a sudden shift but a gradual transition. For most of his career, he was a professor at Princeton. His move toward philanthropy began when Jim Simons, cofounder of the Simons Foundation, invited him to New York to help establish the Center for Computational Astrophysics within the Flatiron Institute. While the setting was new, the mission felt familiar. At Princeton, Spergel had worked within a department that had been a global leader in astrophysics for nearly a century, and his role as chair was to sustain that excellence. At Flatiron, the challenge was different but equally compelling: building a world-class research institute in computational astrophysics from the ground up.
He describes the experience as similar to launching a start-up. From the beginning, the institute focused on shaping its own culture and forging deep ties with nearby universities, including New York University, Columbia, the City University of New York, Rutgers, Stony Brook, and Princeton. The goal was to create an intellectual hub centered on computation, one that could naturally connect astrophysics with fields such as biology, neuroscience, quantum materials, and mathematics.
For more than two decades, Jim and Marilyn Simons personally guided the foundation. Marilyn led many of the efforts linking science with society and culture, while Jim, in addition to serving as board chair, acted as the foundation’s chief scientific decision-maker. Their hands-on approach created a highly effective philanthropic organization. When Spergel was later asked to become president, he saw an opportunity to help shape how private funding could most effectively support science.
Moving from being a practicing scientist to leading a grantmaking organization required a shift in perspective. Spergel notes that the federal government remains the primary supporter of basic research, so foundations like Simons must think carefully about how to complement public funding rather than duplicate it. He compares the relationship to contrapuntal music: the government plays one line, and philanthropy adds another that enriches the overall structure. This often means crossing boundaries that are harder for federal agencies to navigate, such as supporting interdisciplinary work or international collaborations. The Simons Foundation, for example, funds collaborative research groups led by scientists across the United States and Europe, arrangements that would be far more complex for government agencies to establish.
Today, the entire US research system is facing significant uncertainty as federal science agencies confront potential funding and staffing cuts. Spergel is clear that philanthropy cannot replace government support. Private giving accounts for roughly 10% of total science funding, with much of it concentrated in biomedical research. Even a substantial increase in philanthropic spending would barely offset large-scale federal cuts. Proposed reductions of up to 50% for agencies such as NASA, the National Science Foundation, and the National Institutes of Health would be catastrophic and impossible for philanthropy to absorb.
Spergel sees two possible paths forward. One is that the proposed cuts prove temporary and funding stabilizes. The other is a more fundamental shift in the government’s relationship with science. At this point, he believes it is unclear which future will prevail. In either case, he argues that philanthropy’s immediate responsibility is to stand firmly behind scientists and the broader research community.
In response to these challenges, the Simons Foundation has adjusted its grantmaking strategy. Rather than launching new research initiatives, the foundation is focusing on supporting early-career scientists, who are particularly vulnerable in the current climate. The scale of the problem is stark. In mathematics alone, the number of advertised tenure-track faculty positions dropped from about 150 in 2024 to around 70 in 2025. Simons-funded positions account for 10 of those roles. While philanthropy cannot solve the broader crisis, it can meaningfully support the next generation of researchers.
More broadly, the foundation is funding 55 faculty positions for three years across mathematics, physics, biology, and neuroscience at both public and private universities in New York State. Spergel hopes this regional approach, potentially combined with state support, can serve as a model for other philanthropic organizations.
Universities themselves are under intense pressure. Uncertainty around funding, changes to overhead policies, and broader political shifts have led many institutions to sharply reduce hiring. Spergel describes these decisions as rational responses to uncertainty, even if their consequences are painful. He also raises a sensitive but important point: if more senior faculty members chose to retire, it could significantly improve job prospects for younger scholars.
At the same time, universities are being forced to reassess their priorities. Spergel notes that effective leadership requires asking difficult questions about what an institution does exceptionally well and where it may be spreading itself too thin. At Simons, for instance, the foundation has concluded that its greatest impact in areas like autism research lies in supporting fundamental science rather than applied programs.
For young people considering careers in astrophysics or other scientific fields, Spergel’s advice is to continue doing the best possible work. Even under pessimistic scenarios, opportunities will still exist for those producing outstanding research. He also encourages optimism, pointing out that advances in artificial intelligence have increased demand for the skills held by science PhD graduates. Many of his former students have built fulfilling and impactful careers in industry.
Across philanthropy, Spergel sees growing cooperation among funders, particularly around preserving valuable scientific datasets that may be threatened by budget cuts. Climate records, public health data, and vaccination databases are all examples of resources that are critical not only for current research but also for training future AI systems. High-quality, unbiased data are essential; without them, AI tools can produce misleading results.
He also hopes the current moment will attract new participants to science philanthropy. Many individuals have built great wealth by leveraging advances in science and technology, and some of today’s scientists and technologists are becoming increasingly interested in giving back to the research ecosystem. Expanding the scale of science philanthropy, he believes, would be one positive outcome amid the uncertainty.
Looking ahead, Spergel expects independent research institutes like the Flatiron Institute to play an increasingly important role. One of the strengths of the US scientific system, he argues, is its diversity. Federal agencies, national laboratories, universities, and privately funded institutes all contribute in different ways. Philanthropic organizations, in particular, can operate on longer timescales and take greater risks than government funders. Spergel likens this approach to venture capital: meaningful breakthroughs often require accepting that some projects will fail.
Spergel has also remained deeply involved with NASA, most recently as cochair of the science team for the Roman Space Telescope, which now faces possible cancellation due to budget cuts. He emphasizes that NASA is uniquely capable of carrying out large-scale space missions and remains a global leader in space science. In his view, the initial budget proposals targeting NASA were poorly conceived, especially given that projects like Roman have been well managed, ahead of schedule, and under budget.
His service to NASA also includes cochairing a committee examining unidentified aerial phenomena, formerly known as UFOs. Despite the conspiracy theories surrounding the topic, Spergel agreed to lead the effort out of a sense of responsibility. Most reported sightings can be explained as aircraft or drones, but a small fraction remain ambiguous. From a scientific standpoint, unexplained observations warrant careful study. History offers many examples, such as atmospheric phenomena once dismissed because they were difficult to observe.
The committee recommended creating tools, including a public reporting app, to help collect better data. Spergel sees this as a way to both engage the public and build trust in science. With enough high-quality observations, most reports can be explained, and occasionally something genuinely interesting may emerge.
Asked about the overall outlook for science, Spergel describes it as deeply uncertain. There is a hopeful scenario in which the research community emerges stronger after a difficult period, using the disruption to improve efficiency and reduce unnecessary bureaucracy. There is also a darker possibility in which the United States cedes its global leadership in science, with profound economic and strategic consequences.
Spergel is particularly worried about the young scientists who may leave research altogether due to a lack of opportunities, as well as students who decide not to pursue graduate education. Despite these concerns, he remains hopeful that political leaders will ultimately recognize the value of the scientific enterprise and avoid decisions that could permanently damage a system built over generations.







Leave a Reply