
WASHINGTON — A new analysis released by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine outlines a series of urgent steps the U.S. government should take to preserve and strengthen America’s global leadership in science and technology. The report argues that the U.S. must move beyond its long-standing strategy of trying to shield individual technologies from foreign access and instead focus on safeguarding the nation’s overall ability to innovate.
According to the committee that authored the report, the shifting dynamics of global competition demand a new mindset. Susan Gordon, former principal deputy director of national intelligence and co-chair of the committee, emphasized that protecting single technologies is no longer enough. She noted that concentrating solely on preventing competitor nations from accessing specific tools can not only fall short but may at times work against U.S. interests. In her view, maintaining and expanding America’s innovative capacity is equally — and increasingly — essential in meeting both commercial and national security challenges.
The report calls on the federal government to maximize research that can be carried out in open and collaborative environments. Committee members argue that open science remains one of the United States’ greatest strengths, drawing top global talent, accelerating discovery, and contributing to breakthroughs that shape future industries. The authors recommend that the president issue an executive order encouraging agencies to support such openness wherever appropriate.
Still, the National Academies acknowledge that not every area of research should be conducted without restrictions. They propose that the federal government develop a coordinated interagency process to identify and evaluate risks that threaten the country’s technological edge. This framework would inform strategies for managing vulnerabilities and ensure consistent implementation across relevant departments.
A Changing Landscape Calls for New Policies
For decades, U.S. policies intended to protect technological advantages were designed around controlling a relatively small set of critical technologies. These technologies often had direct connections to national security or economic strength, making them suitable targets for export controls or other restrictions. Such measures were effective when scientific development was more centralized and when emerging technologies had clear, limited applications.
But today’s environment is very different. Heightened concern about maintaining leadership in areas such as biotechnology, artificial intelligence, machine learning, and quantum technologies has prompted calls for strict controls. Yet the report warns that ramping up restrictions is unlikely to achieve the intended results — and may even stunt American innovation.
One key reason is that technological progress increasingly comes from the commercial sector. Defense-related capabilities now rely heavily on technologies first developed for consumer markets or private industry. Additionally, modern research is more global and interdisciplinary, complicating efforts to isolate specific technologies from the broader ecosystem.
Many emerging tools are built upon large, interconnected technology platforms — such as advanced telecommunications networks or the global internet — that serve numerous commercial, social, and scientific purposes. Attempting to restrict knowledge or use of these platforms could disrupt countless other applications, making such measures impractical and harmful.
Global Competition Has Intensified
The report also highlights the rapidly evolving competitive environment. Other nations have developed strong research and development networks, making it unrealistic to expect that blocking access to U.S. technologies will keep foreign competitors from building similar capabilities. China, in particular, is identified as a formidable near-peer competitor. Over the past twenty years, it has invested heavily in R&D, built a technically skilled labor force many times larger than that of the United States, and aggressively pursued initiatives to achieve dominance in key technological fields.
The study notes that China also acquires technology through corporate purchases, talent recruitment programs, and the theft of intellectual property. At the same time, U.S. responses have often involved establishing layers of oversight and bureaucracy that inadvertently slow down domestic innovation — the very outcome the policies seek to prevent.
Within the U.S. research community, the rules governing science and technology have expanded significantly in both volume and complexity. Numerous agencies, each with its own directives and requirements, contribute to a regulatory environment that the report describes as cumbersome. These conditions can inhibit collaboration, deter global talent, and slow the pace of discovery.
Patrick Gallagher, chancellor of the University of Pittsburgh and co-chair of the committee, warned that trying to manage new global risks through increasingly rigid restrictions can undermine the country’s competitiveness. He stressed that excessive controls can obstruct research progress and weaken the environment that has long fueled America’s scientific leadership.
Recommendations for a More Resilient Innovation System
To address these challenges, the report presents a strategic set of recommendations aimed at reinforcing America’s innovation capacity while responsibly managing risks. The authors call for a balanced approach that protects essential national interests without stifling scientific openness or slowing technological advancement.
The study was conducted by the Committee on Protecting Critical Technologies for National Security in an Era of Openness and Competition and was supported by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency and the National Science Foundation. The National Academies — independent, nonprofit institutions operating under an 1863 charter signed by President Abraham Lincoln — provide neutral guidance on scientific, technological, and medical issues to inform U.S. policy decisions.






Leave a Reply